Showing posts with label McGettigan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label McGettigan. Show all posts

Monday, August 18

Trial transcripts add evidence that Spanier was Corbett's ultimate target in Sandusky investigation

A sidebar discussing the possible use of e-mail evidence during the Sandusky trial revealed that the PA OAG wasn't going to try the cases of Curley and Schultz

By
Ray Blehar

In my February 1, 2014 blogpost, titled "Sandusky scandal marked by deception, suppression and manipulation," I posited the theory that a political vendetta by Tom Corbett against Graham Spanier was the critical turning point in the Sandusky case.  The timeline below, which shows that the case took off after the Corbett-Spanier budget battle, as well as other evidence, supported that theory.

























The timeline not only supports the theory that the budget battle was the most important catalyst of the Sandusky investigation, but negated the theory that electoral politics were what caused the investigation to lag.  

Other evidence supporting the budget battle theory includes that PSU officials were informed (on or about January 31, 2012) that "Fina expected Curley and Schultz to flip,' the failure to charge Spanier at the same time as Curley and Schultz, the chain of custody and tampering issues regarding the e-mail evidence, and Baldwin's forced "flip-flop" on Spanier.


Trial Transcripts Provide More Evidence

While reviewing the 6-18-2012 Sandusky trial transcripts (pps. 162175)-back in June of this past year, I took particular notice to a sidebar discussion regarding the possible use (by the defense) of the grand jury transcripts of Curley, Schultz, and Spanier as a method of impeaching the testimony of Mike McQueary.  

After some discussion, defense counsel Karl Rominger then limited his request to just pages 3 through 8 of Tim Curley' s testimony. As the discussion continued, prosecutor Joseph McGettigan brought up that their side could use the e-mails and Schultz's notes,as well as the perjury charges, as "tremendous contrary evidence."  

Not long after that, Judge Cleland began discussion and brought up the concept that the Commonwealth could have been using the indictments against Curley and Schultz to "hamstring the defense" in the Sandusky case (see page 169).  However, as it concerns Spanier, Judge Cleland's comment that use of the email and other evidence might compromise the OAG's case against Curley and Schultz is the more critical discussion.


McGettigan: "We're not
going to try that case."

























As the discussion continued, Judge Cleland was "thinking out loud" that the use of the email and other evidence might compromise Curley and Schultz's right to fair trial down the road.  

Seconds later, prosecutor Joseph McGettingan made the surprising admission that the Commonwealth was "not going to try that case."  The latter statement supporting the existing evidence that the OAG's strategy was to get Curley and Schultz to flip on Spanier (after Spanier was charged).




"Flip" would save Commonwealth's weak case

The Commonwealth's case against Spanier is flimsily supported by the grand jury testimony of former PSU General Counsel Cynthia Baldwin and three emails, only one of which  contains anything of substance, and even it is of dubious provenance.

Baldwin
As I wrote back in December 2013, Baldwin's grand jury testimony has been refuted by practically everyone else who had some role in the case, including Spanier, PSU PR employee Lisa Powers, PSU IT employee John Corro,  OAG employees Braden Cook and Agent Sassano and even members of the PSU Board of Trustees.  


Baldwin's testimony was refuted by
everyone else in the Sandusky case
If Curley and Schultz were not facing charges, they too would have refuted Baldwin's testimony, however their pre-grand jury interviews managed to do just that.  Baldwin contended that she had met on several occasions with the PSU Three to discuss grand jury Subpoena 1179, which requested files relating to the 2002 (sic) incident involving Sandusky and any other known incidents.  Ironically, at their pre-grand jury police interviews (Exhibit B) neither Curley or Schultz knew the year of the incident, with Schultz believing it took place sometime after 2003 and Curley stating it was in 2000.  It's a stretch to believe Baldwin told them to search for records but didn't tell them the year in which the incident occurred.

Then there's Baldwin herself, who can only be described as duplicitous in her representation of the PSU Three.  When asked the question if she represented Tim and Gary, she evaded answering by simply stating that Tim was an employee and Gary was retired.  In Spanier's case, before he testified she told the grand jury judge (page 28)  that she "represents the University solely," then did not correct the record when Spanier identified her as his counsel (page 3).  

Baldwin also "flipped' her position on Spanier, first telling government investigators who were processing his security clearance that he was "a man of integrity" but later told a grand jury (page 70) the exact opposite, "that he was not a man of integrity. He lied to me."  Baldwin's alleged change of heart about Spanier came after the Freeh Report was released. That argument doesn't hold water either, because there was no evidence about Spanier in the Freeh Report that Baldwin shouldn't have already seen (save the one tampered e-mail).  Even so, that e-mail doesn't refute Spanier's claim of believing horseplay took place in 2001.

I doubt the Commonwealth has much confidence that Baldwin's testimony would be believed by a jury.


E-mail Chain of Custody
The prosecution, Spanier/PSU critics, and the media all seem to believe that a February 27-28, 2001 email of which Spanier was a conversant, provides "rock solid evidence" that Spanier, Curley, and Schultz decided not to report Sandusky to the authorities.  It was in that email that Spanier allegedly wrote "then we become vulnerable for not reporting it."  

One of the reasons they believe it is because they are oblivious to the chain of custody issue  regarding all of the e-mail evidence used in the case.


Freeh Report findings about Paterno and
 e-mails refuted by Fina, Moulton, and others
Snippets of the e-mail were first leaked in the press in mid-June 2012, just before the Sandusky trial.  Media coverage of the e-mail leaks then became more prominent at the end of June, with CNN leading the reporting.  The full e-mails were released as part of the Freeh Report as the most important evidence in the case.  According to former FBI-Director Louis Freeh, they proved not only a cover up, but that Joe Paterno was the only intervening factor that caused PSU officials not to report Sandusky to the proper authorities.  

In September 2013, Freeh's allegation that Paterno was part of the cover-up was refuted by lead prosecutor Frank Fina.   

But Fina was not the only person to refute Freeh's e-mail assertions.

All of the e-mail evidence used in the case were from the mail folders of Gary Schultz.   At the report press conference, Freeh announced that his team had made "independent discovery" of the e-mail evidence on March 20, 2012.  

"Our investigative team made independent discovery of critical 1998 and 2001 emails – the most important evidence in this investigation."

Freeh's statement was refuted by testimony at the July 2013 preliminary hearing of the PSU Three, Spanier's grand jury proceedings, and by Geoffrey Moulton's investigation.  The media, particularly the Wall Street Journal (whom I contacted personally) refused to print these revelations, thus the public has yet to learn that Freeh lied about the e-mail (and other evidence) during his press conference. 

At the preliminary hearing,  PSU IT department employee John Corro testified that he had provided three thumb drives containing emails in response to Subpoena 1179 to Cynthia Baldwin in April 2011 (page 89).  Furthermore OAG computer forensics expert Braden Cook stated that in March 2012, he realized the Schultz e-mails were missing from the inventory.  Cook then stated he received Schultz's network file share on a DVD from the OAG computer unit on March 23, 2012 (page 107).   

Then PSU-Counsel Cynthia Baldwin informed the court at Spanier's April 2011 colloquy (page 27) that the PSU IT Department (i.e., PSU's SOS unit) was searching for the e-mails related to Subpoena 1179 and she promised to turn them over by April 15, 2011.

To recap to this point, four different timeframes were mentioned regarding the turnover of the email evidence:  April 2011 (Corro); April 15, 2011 (Baldwin); March 20, 2012 (Freeh); and March 23, 2012 (Cook).  

It doesn't stop there.


Kelly:  Obstruction allegations re: email
have been refuted by the Moulton report.
The Conspiracy of Silence grand jury presentment (page 32) alleged that the emails and other evidence were not searched for and found until the first four months of 2012.  In addition, it alleged (page 22) that the PSU IT department (SOS) was not used to find the email evidence until after the arrests of Curley and Schultz.  Both allegations are patently false, given that Corro is an SOS employee and testified to searching for and obtaining the emails in April 2011.



After five different dates/time-frames, Geoffrey Moulton put the final nail in the coffin at #6.

#6:  The Final Nail
The report of the Sandusky investigation (page 158)  by Special Deputy Attorney General Geoffrey Moulton  revealed (as part of the investigation timeline )that a thumb-drive containing the Penn State e-mail evidence was turned over to Trooper Scott Rossman on July 7, 2011.  


"July 7, 2011.  Tpr. Rossman receives a thumb drive containing Penn State emails. "

Therefore, the Moulton Report disproved not only Freeh's statement of independent discovery by his team in March 2012, but also disproved the former-AG Linda Kelly's allegations in the Conspiracy of Silence presentment that the e-mails were not turned over by PSU until the first four months of 2012.  

The analysis and conclusions regarding the e-mail evidence (which could be tossed due to chain of custody) also lends credence to the theory that getting Curley and/or Schultz to implicate Spanier was the preferred, if not the only way, that the OAG could get a conviction.  

E-mail Tampering
Moulton's verification of the true date that the e-mails finally made their way to the lead investigator also lends credence to my theory of evidence tampering.   If the e-mail evidence, particularly from 27-28 February 2001, was turned over in April 2011, then Spanier could have been (wrongly) charged with failure to report child abuse at the same time as Curley and Schultz.

The likely reason Spanier wasn't charged is because the contents of the e-mail in April 2011 didn't match the contents of the e-mail that was included in the Freeh Report.

Given that Freeh's computers were not part of the University system, any information processed on them could have been subject to alteration and there would be no audit trail left behind at PSU.  When Freeh packed up and left State College, you can bet his computer hard drives were either wiped or trashed as not to leave an evidence trail.

Forensic analysis of the email in question by document and computer forensics experts all concluded the e-mail was suspicious and needed to be compared with an original version of the e-mail from the PSU server.   The interpersed html code, specifically the single " " within the response by Curley, as well as the fact that Schultz signature block, not Spanier's should be at the bottom are indications of suspected tampering. 





The appearance of html tags in the body of emails can occur when when converting a
Eudora mailbox to Outlook.  In this case there were five Eudora emails from the February 2001 time-frame included as evidence exhibits in the Freeh Report.  Only two of the five have the interspersed html code and in both cases, contain the wrong signature block, which (not so) coincidentally belonged to Spanier.   Those emails were likely subject to tampering.

When the e-mails were tampered with, they were first downloaded from Eudora as plain text files and edited in Outlook in rich text (or html).  They were likely messy looking when downloaded, but to no avail, Freeh's team went about its business. When the changes were made, they were saved back to the Eudora mail box with the messy html still visible. 

My review of the Freeh Report appendices found that nearly of dozen e-mails and documents showed signs of tampering. This evidence has been turned over to law enforcement.


Fina's statement to PSU officials

Despite the lack of openness we've experienced from the Penn State administration recently, Universities are rather open environments and not of the mindset of the ways in which seemingly benign information can be very valuable to an adversary.  As a result, Universities, including PSU, are not very proficient at safeguarding information and data.  

As a result of these deficiencies, information related to the Sandusky case and subsequent NCAA investigation was not properly safeguarded and made its way outside the University.  Among that information was Fina's statement to PSU officials that he "expected Curley and Schultz to flip."  

In addition, other leaked information revealed that Schultz had been approached by the Commonwealth and asked to testify against Spanier.  Schultz refused to do so, allegedly telling the prosecution that he wasn't going to perjure himself to implicate Spanier, especially when he was already facing perjury charges.

Conclusion

In summary, Fina is on the record as expecting Curley and Schultz to "flip."  McGettigan is on the record stating that the Commonwealth "wasn't going to try that case" (i.e., Curley and Schultz).  It seems clear that by June 2012, the OAG was getting the charges ready against Spanier and believed that Curley and Schultz would testify against the former President to save their own backsides.   That didn't happen.

AG Kathleen Kane has been steadfast in her statements about prosecuting the case, however, the key driver there appears to be politics.  As we saw in the un-prosecutable Ali bribery case, Kane's opponents in the GOP and the media went after her relentlessly for not prosecuting four Democratic legislators who accepted gifts totaling  $16,500.  Meanwhile, the informant, Ali, had been given "the deal of the century" by former prosecutor Fina, who dismissed over 2,000 charges related to a fraud of $430,000. 


Schultz, Spanier, and Curley: Being scapegoated to
cover up the failures of PA's child protection system
I suspect that Judge Hoover and Kane are waiting for the Federal investigation of The Second Mile to conclude in order to have the political cover to ditch the case of the PSU Three.

When, and if that happens, how long will it take for  the media realize the whole case against PSU was a smokescreen to cover up the failures of PA's child protection system and of The Second Mile in the Sandusky case?  And that the Freeh investigation was a complete sham.


Wednesday, July 2

Freed and DA's Feign Indignation Over "Strawman" Attack on Prosecutors

Former AG candidate David Freed and the PA DA's shot at Kathleen Kane for her "attack" on the Sandusky prosecutors will come back to bite them later.

By
Ray Blehar

Pennsylvania has nothing on bizarro world.

After reading the lunacy of Jennifer Storm's Op-Ed on Monday, I thought we'd seen the depths of insanity.

I was wrong.

Yesterday, former AG candidate (loser) David Freed and the PA District Attorneys association rebuked current AG Kathleen Kane for her "attacks" on Sandusky prosecutors Frank Fina and Joe McGettigan.  The notion that Kane "attacked" the prosecutors is a "strawman."  In other words, a misrepresentation or exaggeration of the facts.

This so-called attack consisted of ONE misstatement by Kane that a victim who was abused during the lagging Sandusky investigation was not one of the victims presented at the trial.  While this was a mistake, it was hardly an attack on prosecutors.

The Moulton report went exceptionally light on the prosecutors, stating the decisions made in the investigation were within their prosecutorial discretion.  However, the report cited numerous inexplicable delays in the investigation.  For example, the failure to obtain search warrants and the failure to establish a multi-disciplinary team -- the latter is required by statute.

DA's Backing of Prosecutors 

Freed contradicted his own campaign promise to investigate the Sandusky case in this passage of his Op-Ed (hat tip, JimmyW).

"Although we never perceived a need for the investigation recently concluded by Geoffrey Moulton, a former prosecutor and an associate professor at Widener University School of Law, into the conduct of the Sandusky prosecution, we certainly agree that the report was seriously undertaken, professionally written, and measured in its conclusions."

Freed and the DAs apparently believe the successful prosecution of Sandusky and that Sandusky will be in jail the rest of his life outweighs the fact that two chiildren were abused while Sandusky was under investigation.

It appears that this group is also too interested in "winning the news cycle" than they are to actually check the facts of the case.  Instead, they are willing to blindly stand behind the admonitions of Fina and McGettigan, who claim there was uncertainty about the dates of the Victim 9 crimes and that the other case was couldn't be prosecuted because the victim wasn't credible.

Accusing a victim of not being credible is quite rich coming from Frank Fina and Joe McGettigan - especially when making claims about dates (and locations of crimes).

Again, I am sure the DA's association and the media, particularly Angela Columbus at the Inquirer and Charles Thompson of the Patriot News, haven't a clue about the changes to dates and locations of crimes during the Sandusky prosecution.

If they had known, I suspect it wouldn't have made a difference.  The truth was the other "victim" in the Sandusky case.

Prosecutors Changes to Dates and Locations of Crimes

While child victims are given considerable latitude in recalling the dates of their abuse, the changes to the Bills of Particulars in the Sandusky case reek of manipulation.   The dates for Victims 1, 2, 3, 5, 8, and 9 all changed considerably between the grand jury, the Bills of Particulars, and the trial.  The Victim 5, 8, and 9 cases are especially troubling.

Viictim 8 was the unknown victim who was allegedly seen by the janitor.  Here's the essential details.
Grand Jury:  Abused in Fall 2000, in Assistant Coaches Locker Room.
BoP 1: Abused Fall 2000, in Assistant Coaches Locker Room
BoP 2: Abused on  Nov 20-27, 2000, in Assistant Coaches Locker Room.
Trial Testimony:  Abused on a Thursday or Friday on either the weekend of September 23, 2000 or the weekend of November 11, 2000 in Staff Locker Room

Analysis:  The change to the location was due to the defense raising the issue of an obstruction blocking the view, as testified to by the hearsay witness at the grand jury.  In order to solve the problem, Fina moved the location to the obstruction free Staff Locker Room.  The date it occurred is anyone's guess, however, adults are allegedly held to a higher standard of recall than children.  That didn't happen here.

Victim 5 was a boy who met Sandusky in 1995 or 1996 around age 8.  As with most of the Sandusky victims, his grand jury testimony revealed he met Sandusky in his first year of camp then Sandusky began associating with him shortly afterward.  At   Here are the essential details:
Grand Jury: Abused once in 1998 in the East Area Locker Room.
BoP1:  Multiple abuse incidents from 1996 to 2002 in East Area Locker Room.
BoP2:   Single incident in Lasch Building in August 2001.
Trial Testimony:  Single incident in Lasch Building in August 2001.

Analysis:  The 2001 date does not fit Sandusky's pattern of meeting a child and taking him to work out within the first two years of contact.  The location change is also troubling, given the Lasch Building and the East Area Locker Room are of completely different architectures.  FYI:  Spanier, Curley and Schultz are being prosecuted for Endangering the Welfare of Children for this victim.

Victim 9 came forward after the initial November 4, 2011 grand jury presentment.  His dates also fluctuate considerably. Here are the essential details:

Grand Jury: Abused from 2004 to 2008.
BoP1:  Abused from summer 2005 and 2009 when he was age 13 to 15/16.
BoP2:  Abused July 2005 to December 2008 when he was age 12 to 15.
Trial Testimony:  Under direct examination said his abuse took place until he was 15 or 16.  Under cross examination, Victim 9 definitively stated abuse stopped at age 16.

Analysis:  The December 2008 date conveniently absolves the Pennsylvania Department of Public Welfare and the OAG and PSP from any blame for abuse that took place while Sandusky was under investigation.  Under the Public Welfare Code, the county agency was required to work with Second Mile to put a protection plan in place while Sandusky was under investigation.  That didn't happen.


Victim 2 is probably the most famous date change in the case, from the McQueary incident. Here are the essential details:
Grand Jury: Abused on the Friday before Spring break in 2002.
BoP1:  March 1, 2002.
BoP2:  February 9, 2001.
Trial Testimony:  February 9, 2001.



Analysis:  Agent Sassano testified that TV Guides were used to set the date.  The Moulton report stated a thumbdrive containing PSU's emails was provided to the police in July 2011.  Logic dictates that the emails, which included discussions of the McQueary incident, were used to set the date.  The emails were received before charges were filed, thus the OAG ignored them and used McQueary's incorrect date of 2002 for the purpose of charging PSU officials with failure to report.  Had they used the 2001 date for this crime, it would have fallen outside the statute of limitations.

Victim 3's case was simply all over the place. Here are the essential details:
Grand Jury: Abused during 2000 in the PSU gym and Sandusky's home.
BoP1:  Abused from late summer to late 2000 in Sandusky's home and the Lasch Building.
BoP2:  Abused July 1999 to December 2001.
Trial Testimony:  Abused while Sandusky was an active coach in 1999.

Analysis:  Despite manipulation of the dates, the victim testified that his contact with Sandusky was while he was an active coach and sometime into the year 2000.  Sandusky retired in December 1999.  FYI:  Spanier, Curley and Schultz are being prosecuted for Endangering the Welfare of Children for this victim.

Victim 1's case also reveals discrepancies in the dates.  Victim 1's grand jury testimony was that he met Sandusky in 2004 or 2005 and didn't begin spending time with him until the 2007 track season.
Grand Jury:  Abused during 2007 and 2008.
BoP1: Abused from 2005 to 2008.
BoP 2: Abused between June 2005 and September 2008.
Trial Testimony: Testified to meeting Sandusky in 2004 and got to know him better in the second or  third year - 2005 or 2006. Began staying at his house then.  Fisher reported Sandusky's abuse in November 2008.

Analysis/Additional Informtion:  Despite Fisher stating he met Sandusky at age 10 in 2004 and didn't get to know him until two or three years later, McGettigan repeatedly asked Fisher if he was abused at age 10.  

The information above is all on the public record and it shows that any statements about the dates of crimes by Fina and McGettigan should be taken with a grain of salt.

Date changes were just the tip of the iceberg in the Sandusky prosecution.

More Irregularities at the Trial

If you want to take these men at their word, before doing so you should know that they coached one of the witnesses into claiming he was of belly-button height on Sandusky when he was 14 years old.  The Center for Disease Control height and weight chart reveals that a child of that height would be off the chart at the low end.  In addition, photographic evidence revealed that particular victim was at Sandusky's shoulder height one year later (that would equate to a growth spurt of approximately 20 inches -- again, off the charts).

You can read more about other irregularities at the Sandusky trial here starting on page 48.

There was a lot more to this trial than convictions on 45 of 48 counts and those who have pointed to the Sandusky case as a successful prosecution may eventually end up eating their words.


Tuesday, September 3

McGettigan's and Fina's Conduct Questionable At Sandusky Trial

Despite statements to the opposite, prosecutors put PSU on trial along with Sandusky, with eyes on future prosecutions of Curley, Schultz, and Spanier.  

By
Ray Blehar

Prosecutor McGettigan’s opening statement provided a preview of what would be the Commonwealth’s ongoing tactic of "anchoring" the idea of conspiracy and cover-up by PSU officials during the Sandusky trial, while leveling no culpability on The Second Mile.  To wit:

“Now is it possible that earlier signs of abuse were observed or heard by persons involved in The Second Mile occurred (sic)? No.  Were the Pennsylvania State University heard? I don’t know.  Is it possible those signs could have been responded to in a different benefaction? Indeed.”

McGettigan would later say that neither PSU or The Second Mile was on trial, but it was clear PSU was definitely in the prosecution's sights -- even though it is a fact that the charity knew of the 2001 allegation against Sandusky and did nothing.

For example, Second Mile Board Member, Bruce Heim, made the following statement:

“For five years, I worked out at the football facility, several times a week, and saw Jerry showering with children.  I said I don’t think it’s relevant. It happens every day at the YMCA. I remember the conversation specifically because it seemed like a nonstarter because of what Penn State said went on.”

But this trial was going to be about PSU's culpability whenever possible and McGettigan and Fina made that happen.

Victim 4

McGettigan and Fina's slanting of the facts did not stop at the opening statement but was evident when he called Victim 4 to the stand first. Victim 4 testified that all of his abuse took place on the PSU campus or at football related events, such as overnight bowl trips and pre-game activities at Toftrees.  He is the only victim in the Sandusky case to stay over at Sandusky's home and claim never to be abused there.  

The prosecution introduced numerous evidence exhibits during Victim 4's testimony that were football related, such as photographs of players with Victim 4, video clips of the victim, photos from the Alamo Bowl, and pictures of the PSU locker rooms.   This was all done up front to seal the narrative tying Sandusky's abuse of the victims to his role as a PSU football coach.

The following passage from the Washington Post's Joel Achenbach confirmed the effectiveness of McGettigan’s “anchoring” strategy that began with Victim 4 and continued throughout the trial:

“The prosecution had won the case on the very first day of testimony, when “Victim 4” took the stand and told his story. He was devastatingly credible. He spoke frankly, graphically. It was a brave performance, prefiguring the courage of the other seven victims who came forward later. When Victim 4 was at his most vulnerable as a boy, lacking a father figure, Sandusky had swooped in like a guardian angel…Sandusky had an abnormal fixation on the boy not yet in high school”

Victim 2

The prosecution's strategy to treat Victim 2 as an "unknown" individual also was highly questionable, if not unethical.   Victim 2 - who recently received a settlement from PSU - gave a statement to an FBI trained investigator that he was not abused during the incident witnessed by McQueary.   Based on the voicemail messages of Jerry Sandusky, it is presumed that Victim 2 was interviewed by the police in September of 2011 and, according the multiple sources, vehemently denied abuse took place.  Rather than call Victim 2 as a witness and have him possibly impeach the testimony of Mike McQueary, they lied to the jury and told them that they did not know the identity of the victim.  The defense team went along with the charade because they were not sure how Victim 2 would testify either.  He had obtained a civil lawyer and was now suing Sandusky for abuse.   

Quite frankly, the Victim 2 episode was just one of many occasions where the prosecutors (and judge) made a mockery of the system.

At the sentencing hearing, McGettigan made this blasphemous statement about Victim 2  (and Victim 8)...

"And two others will not speak because they're identities are known only to themselves, this defendant, and God. Perhaps the year has caused their silence or undeserving shame but the jury rightly did them justice and I speak for them and their rights to justice as well as those who testified before Your Honor."


Unfortunately for Frank Fina, Victim 2 is probably going to make an appearance at the trials of Curley, Schultz, and Spanier and things are sure to get very interesting.

Victim 3

At trial, Victim 3 testified that he met Sandusky in 1998 and stayed at Sandusky’s house over a three-year span (1998-2000).   However, Victim 3’s testimony on page 95 stated that his attendance at football games occurred only when Sandusky was an active coach, thus placing his interactions with Sandusky up to the year  2000.  Victim 3 stated he attended five games, which would be less than a full season’s slate of home games.

Victim 3’s admission of contact with Sandusky in 2001 was established in response to a question from prosecutor McGettigan in which he moved the last year of the three-year span of contact to 2001.

Not so ironically, Agent Anthony Sassano could not recall Victim 3 as one of the "endangered" children when he testified at the preliminary hearing on July 30, 2013 (page 7).

 Victim 5

The case of Victim 5 was discussed somewhat extensively in this blogpost.  It's clear from the Bill of Particulars that the date was changed from 1998 to 2001 to put Victim 5 in the timeframe for being "endangered" by the alleged failures of Curley, Schultz, and Spanier to make a report.

PSU's lawyers jumped on the bandwagon here as well, stating that the Victim 5 crime could have been prevented if PSU had acted on McQueary's report.  This is rather strong evidence that the PSU BOT is in bed with the prosecutors in ensuring that their firing of Spanier and Paterno is "upheld" by the trial verdicts in the upcoming trial.

Victim 8/Janitor Incident

This incident also has the earmarks of highly unethical behavior.  As I reported, the eyewitness janitor was not even working at PSU at the time of the incident and there were numerous other physical and temporal evidence that made the crime impossible, but the unethical aspects of the prosecutors in this incident appear to be three fold. 

First, the crime scene was changed from the Lasch Building Assistant Coach's locker room to the Staff Locker Room.  The reason for the change was the defense had argued that Petrosky could not see above the legs of Sandusky and the victim, thus the eyewitness would have had the same view - and been unable to see the crime.  Fina interjected and changed the crime scene during the defense's argument.  

The next questionable move was in arguing for the admission of the hearsay testimony, the prosecution stated a second janitor, Jay Witherite, would testify to bolster Petrosky's story.   Witherite never testified and no explanation was given for his absence.

The final apparently questionable move on the part of the prosecution was to wait until they had called all of their witnesses, then stipulated that the eye-witness, James Calhoun, was incompetent to testify.  The prosecution did not have a medical record to buttress this claim, nor did they have a letter from a doctor.  They simply said that Dr. Bharat Adroja, if he were present, would say that Calhoun was not competent.  And when did Adroja make this determination?  June 11, 2011 - the first day of the Sandusky trial.

Amazingly, the jury bought this nonsensical story about the janitor and convicted Sandusky on all five charges related to the incident. 

Louis Freeh used this incident to indict Penn State's football culture "from top (Spanier) to the bottom (janitors)" for enabling the abuse of children.

Closing Remarks

McGettigan and Fina will be featured on 60 Minutes Sports.  In earlier airing on CBSNews, the prosecutors stated they believe a cover-up by Schultz, Curley, and Spanier occurred and they stand behind the Freeh Report.  However, Fina stated that he saw no evidence that confirmed Paterno had a role in the cover-up, but went on to say Paterno should have done more.

While there is little doubt that Sandusky committed several crimes involving the abuse of children, there is also little doubt that he didn't receive a fair trial.  And now it appears the Sandusky prosecutors are attempting to ensure the other PSU officials don't get a fair trial either.  See below....




Rule 8.4. Misconduct.
 It is professional misconduct for a lawyer to:
(c)  engage in conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit or misrepresentation; (d)  engage in conduct that is prejudicial to the administration of justice;