Sunday, January 20

House of Cards Rests on McQueary's Faulty Memory

The perjury and conspiracy charges against PSU officials depend on what Mike McQueary SAID, and not what he saw.  And the preliminary hearing transcripts prove he doesn't remember WHAT he said or, perhaps more importantly, WHO he told.

By
Ray Blehar

In the perjury case of Gary Schulz and Tim Curley, it's not what Mike McQueary saw that is in question.  It is what Mike McQueary said he saw.  And based on the preliminary hearing transcripts, he's not so sure what he said and who he told.

At the preliminary perjury hearing for Gary Schultz and Tim Curley, prosecutor Bruce Beemer's first question about what McQueary told the two men was met with a very solid answer.  

Mike firmly answered (with his rehearsed response),  it was "I told them I saw Jerry in the showers with a young boy and that what I had seen was extremely sexual and over the lines and wrong."

His testimony went south after that.

If you're going to press perjury charges and you don't have a corroborating witness, your witness better be rock solid certain of what he said.....and McQueary is anything but rock solid.

What He Said, Part 1

Almost everything McQueary said after that first answer was qualified in by using the words "I would" or "I would not" or similar phrasing that is not definitive.  Experts call it a verbal tic, signaling McQueary was less certain about his testimony. Here are some examples...

Q: Did you describe....the body positioning of the individuals in the shower?
A: I would have given them a rough idea, yes.

Q: When you say a rough idea?
A:  I would have said that Jerry was in there in very close proximity to a young boy with his arms wrapped around him.

Q: Would you have described for them what you believed the act was that you saw occurring in that shower?
A:  Yes.  Again, I would not have used some of the words you previously mentioned but I would have described that it was extremely sexual and that some kind of intercourse was going on.

The examples above were under "friendly" examination by the state's prosecutor.  When McQueary responded under cross examination, it was more of the same, except that he began experiencing memory loss.

Q:  When you met with Mr. Curley, did you say I believe he was having anal intercourse with this boy?
A:   I would not have used the words anal intercourse.  I would have said extremely sexual act and I think it was intercourse.

Q:  Okay. And when you got to this portion of the description did Mr. Curley say anything to you?  Did he follow up asking questions?
A:   I can't recall.  I can't recall that, no ma'am.

Q:  Did he -- do you recall any instructions that he gave you?
A:   No -- only that, what I do recall and what he did do...

Q:  So during this very descriptive statement of yours to Mr. Curley about sex -- a possible sex act in the shower, Mr. Curley didn't -- you don't recall Mr. Curley asking you any questions or stopping and clarifying anything that you were telling him?
A:  I'm not saying he didn't, but I can't recall those questions or if he did ask questions.

Q: But you can recall specifically what you told him?
A: Yes, I can recall what I would have said about what I saw, yes, ma'am.

It is hard to believe that Caroline Roberto, who questioned McQueary, didn't attempt to make Mike be more specific and clarify his qualified statements.  But, maybe that was part of the strategy to get Mike's uncertain testimony on the record.

What He Said, Part 2

I don't know about you, but the words "extremely sexual" and "extreme sex act" were not words I used before this scandal broke.  Chances are, Mike never used them either until he and his father met with the lawyers in the attorney general's office.

John McQueary testified that Mike would have never used the words "horsing around."  He related "That's an archaic term that my dad would have said to me.  I don't think I would have used it, and I haven't used it, and I don't think Mike knows it."

Jeepers H. Christmas!  John McQueary doesn't think Mike knows the term horsing around?  Joe Paterno used that term quite frequently.  It's a very common term, but apparently not in the McQueary household.

"Horsing around" -- not used or known by Mike.

"Extremely sexual" -- used quite frequently by Mike.

Conversations around the McQueary household must have been pretty interesting.  For example:

John M:  Mike, your mom's birthday is coming up.  Don't get her anything for the house, go out and buy her something extremely sexual.

Mike M: I know exactly what you mean, Dad.  I saw some extremely sexual bathrobes at WalMart yesterday.

Mrs. M:  Mike, I just finished frying some eggs and they look extremely sexual -- would you like some?

For John McQueary to posit that Mike wouldn't have told Curley and Schultz it was "horsing around" because its a term Mike wouldn't know is preposterous.  And, the AG's choice of the words to describe the incident --  "extremely sexual" -- is equally preposterous.

It's one thing to have McQueary lie about what he told Curley and Schultz, but if you're going to have McQueary lie, at least have him use some words that are believable.

Who He Told, Part 1

McQueary experienced some memory loss when asked about what he said.  However, that paled in comparison to his memory loss when asked who he told.

From page 62 of the Preliminary Perjury transcript:

Q:  You have gone through with Mr. Beemer all of the people that you confronted and told about the incident.  Did you ever that night confront Mr. Sandusky with what you saw.
A:  No, Never.

McQueary's non-answer to the first part infers that he agreed he had discussed, at the hearing, all of the people he told about the incident.  However, it is well documented (in two cases) that he did tell others about Sandusky showering with a child.  And though this has not been reported in the press, those who played in Second Mile golf tournaments stated there were rumors of Sandusky "horsing around" with boys in the showers.

First, there was the person who reported his message board chat to the Centre County DA.  And there would be other people -- including Mike's brother - who were in the chat as well.

Next, McQueary told an equipment manager about the incident.  There is a footnote on page 88 of the Freeh Report stating: "According to Baldwin's notes, the manager advised her that McQueary had told him "that [McQueary] saw something that changed his life. [McQueary] had to tell Coach Paterno."

Finally, there were rumors at The Second Mile golf tournament during the last decade, that Sandusky was "horsing around" in showers with little boys.  Given the number of coaches and former players who play in the golf tournaments, it's possible that McQueary told others on the coaching staff and former players about what he witnessed.

Who He Told, Part 2

During the time of this scandal the only "witnesses" called to testify about McQueary's testimony were:  Joe Paterno, Jonathon Dranov, John McQueary, Timothy Curley, and Gary Schultz.   And none of the witnesses corroborate McQueary's account of reporting a sexual act -- except John McQueary -- who couldn't even remember testifying at the preliminary hearing.

However, it's clear that there were other people McQueary told, so why haven't they been identified and called as witnesses?

The most likely reason, as it was in the case of Victim 2, is that the other witnesses don't corroborate or, more likely, contradict McQueary's story.

It is likely that the chatters, the equipment manager, and the former players (that Mike told about the incident)  would testify to an account similar to Dr. Dranov's -- that McQueary only heard sounds, the incident happened around a corner, and that Mike saw Sandusky and a child exit the shower.

Where are these witnesses and why haven't we heard from them?

Are they not coming forward for fear of losing their jobs and/or business deals with PSU?

Saturday, January 19

UPDATE: Corbett Took Credit For Firing Paterno

Governor Corbett now wants to be the best friend of the former players.  I guess he believes that everyone forgot his role on November 9th, 2011.

by
Ray Blehar

From StateCollege.com

Paterno and Penn State President Graham Spanier were dismissed Nov. 9, and ESPN cited one senior Penn State faculty member as seeing Corbett at a local bar the next night and calling him effusive.

“It was like a victory celebration,” the faculty member told Outside the Lines. “I remember thinking at the time that it just seemed a strange thing … a kind of gratuitous political piling on.”

That Saturday, the day of the Penn State-Nebraska football game, former player Bob Capretto told ESPN he had a conversation with Corbett about the board’s actions to fire Paterno.

“And the governor said, 'I told them to do it,' " Capretto said. "He was proud of it. I told him, 'You don't realize what you have created here. The damage to Penn State is enormous.' "


In the Outside the Lines piece, Corbett is painted as zealous at the chance to play a role in the Penn State scandal.


 I believe Bob Capretto is telling the truth about what he heard.

And we all know that Corbett tried to make this about the victims with his "Remember the children.  Remember that little boy in the shower" admonition at the PSU BOT conference call.

What a phony.

Corbett did everything he could to NOT bring Sandusky to justice in the latest investigation.

All we need is Paula Ammerman to say, "Governor, your time is up."

Corbett Plans Photo Op with Former Players

Governor Tom Corbett invited former players to his mansion for a photo op this Tuesday.  All part of his plan to win back support of the PSU alumni and supporters and to deflect attention away from his failed investigation of Sandusky.  And does it on the anniversary of JVP's passing!

by
Ray Blehar

The e-mail went out on Tuesday, January 15th.  Much like he did when announcing the Commonwealth's lawsuit against the NCAA, Governor Corbett plans to use Penn State football players as props in this "Hail Mary pass"  to win back favor with PSU supporters and deflect attention away from the state's slipshod investigations of Sandusky.  And he does the most classless thing of all by scheduling it on the anniversary of Paterno's passing.

I can just hear his phony tributes to Joe now.  The lettermen need to pack a healthy supply of barf bags if they attend.

 The e-mail is below.


From: "Bernstein, Luke" <lbernstein@pa.gov>
Date: January 15, 2013 7:10:09 PM
To:  <Redacted>
Subject: Meeting with Governor Corbett

Good evening,
Governor Tom Corbett recently met with Justin Kurpeikis, Todd Rucci, Tim Sweeney and several others in State College.  During their discussion, an idea was presented to have a follow-up meeting with additional Letterman.  Thus, we would like to invite you to attend a meeting at the Governor's Residence with the Governor.  Todd, Justin and Tim will be in attendance and will try to ensure we did not exclude anyone that should be included.
The meeting will take place at 6:30 p.m. on Tuesday, January 22, 2013 at the Governor’s Residence (2035 North Front Street, Harrisburg, PA 17102).
Please RSVP to Bryan Troop (717-787-5825 or brtroop@pa.gov) no later than Sunday, January 20, 2013.  Please RSVP with your name, address, and phone number (preferably day of event contact number).  For security reasons, all attendees will need to have a photo ID.
We look forward to seeing everyone on Tuesday.
Best,
Luke
Luke Bernstein
Deputy Chief of Staff
Office of Governor Tom Corbett


Tom Corbett: Master of Deflection

Whenever Corbett is feeling the heat about the state's investigation of Sandusky -- and Kathleen Kane is launching it -- you can be he'll find a way to deflect the media's attention to another subject.

This is well documented.

August 2012:  Corbett, feeling the heat from child advocacy groups and others to investigate the slow roll of the Sandusky investigation, enlists his media cohorts to write a story about how Clinton County CYS failed to put a safety plan in place at the outset of the investigation.

November 2012:  In a desperate attempt to swing favor in AG candidate David Freed, the son-in-law of LeRoy Zimmerman, who would take a softer approach on the "investigation of the investigation,"  Corbett has AG Linda Kelly file the "Conspiracy of Nonsense" charges against Curley, Schultz, and Spanier to much media hype and fanfare.

January 2013:  With Kathleen Kane's swearing in and the impending "investigation of the investigation" on the horizon, Corbett announces the Commonwealth's lawsuit against the NCAA, using a smattering of former players and PSU students in the photo op.  The press conference is held at the Nittany Lion Inn even though PSU is not endorsing the lawsuit.

The Football Players Fall For the Ruse?

 No doubt, everyone that has a functioning brain (that excludes most in the media) knows the NCAA overstepped its bounds when sanctioning Penn State.  Penn State alumni, supporters, and especially the former football players want the sanctions removed.  As noted above, when Corbett announced the lawsuit, former PSU football players, including former All-American Kenny Jackson, were in the room standing behind the governor.  But Corbett wasn't done using them as props and enlisted the help of the Letterman's Club to round up more bodies for the next photo op.


From: <Redacted>
Date: January 16, 2013, 4:03:39 PM EST
To: <Redacted>
Cc: <Redacted>
Subject: Meeting with Governor Corbett
Dear Former PSU Football Player,
You may have received an email from Governor Corbett extending a invitation to the Governor's Mansion in Harrisburg at 6:30 PM on 22 January for a private meeting.  If you have not, a copy is provided below.  The Governor would like an opportunity to explain in a private setting the details involving the lawsuit against the NCAA.
It is important to note that this affair is for all former Penn State Football players and it does not involve the Penn State Football Letterman's Club nor will the Club make any official statements regarding this lawsuit in any capacity.  The email list that was used was incomplete so please forward the email from the Governor and this email to your network of former players as they are invited as well. We would like as many guys to receive the invite as possible, so please forward this on.  If you are planning to attend, please do so by responding to individual on the email below from the Governor.
Thank you for your consideration and we hope to see you Tuesday.
<3 Players - Redacted>
It is important to note that "former players" are invited and not letttermen because the Letterman's Club is affiliated with PSU.  So, can we expect a statement from "former players" offering their support of the NCAA lawsuit? Or will they see through Corbett and tell him to stick it where the sun doesn't shine.

We'll see.


The Real Reason for the Lawsuit

Corbett plans to use the NCAA lawsuit as a "club" against Kane   You can bet Corbett will blast her for the investigation of the "successful prosecution of Sandusky" instead of focusing her offices resources on more important matters -- meaning do anything other than investigating something that could roll back on him.  Corbett knows his slow-roll investigation put children in danger and he knows DPW and CYS blew it back in 1998 when they could have rolled up Sandusky.

Abe Lincoln said it best.

"You can fool some of the people all of the time, and all of the people some of the time, but you can not fool all of the people all of the time."


Friday, January 18

Did Cynthia Baldwin Commit Perjury In Her 2012 Affidavit?

Based on Attorney General Linda Kelly's Standard for Recalling Events In The Distant Past, Cynthia Baldwin Should Be Charged With Perjury

By
Ray Blehar

Cynthia Baldwin's Affidavit (Exhibit 6A from the Freeh Report) recounts the events that transpired when she briefed the Penn State Board of Trustees on May 11, 2011 regarding the Sandusky investigation.

As the top lawyer at PSU, one would expect that Ms. Baldwin would provide an accurate account of what she discussed at the BOT  meeting.  Perhaps it is an accurate account of her briefing to the BOT, however, it is not an accurate account of the facts regarding what PSU officials testified to or who was involved in the 1998 investigation.  See below.







Given the extremely high standard that applies to Curley, Schultz, and Spanier for remembering the details of incidents that occurred ten and fourteen years prior, it strains credulity that Baldwin could not remember details of events that transpired in the year prior.

Cuff her, Dano.

Wednesday, January 16

Who Knew? Part 2: The Hiring of Cynthia Baldwin

Second Mile donations indicated that some BOT members may have been tipped to the Sandusky investigation in 2009.  Did the Sandusky investigation also lead to the hiring of Baldwin?

By
Ray Blehar

In Who Knew? (Part 1), US Steel (John Surma), Merck (Kenneth Frazier), and Ira Lubert all appeared to begin distancing themselves from The Second Mile around 2009.  Surma's and Frazier's companies dropped their donations to the charity considerably from 2008 to 2009 and Lubert stopped letting the charity use his Greenhills facility to hold their Reading, PA summer camps in 2009 as well.  Lubert also stepped away from TSM's Southeast Region Board of Directors that year.

In June 2009, the PA Office of Attorney General learned of the 1998 Sandusky investigation pertaining to an incident on the Penn State campus.  With the investigation possibly taking a turn in Penn State's direction, did then Governor Ed Rendell  pass that information along to his friend and BOT member, Ira Lubert?  And did Lubert pass that information on to Surma, Frazier, and other trustees?

The Hiring of Cynthia Baldwin

In late summer of 2009, some of the Business and Industry Trustees approached then PSU President Graham Spanier, suggesting that PSU hire its own in-house counsel.   At the time, the General Counsel was Wendell Courtney of the firm, McQuaide-Blasko.  Courtney had an office in Old Main and was given the same treatment as any other Vice-President at PSU.  He was intimately involved in the decision-making processes at Old Main.  McQuaide-Blasko had provided PSU's legal services for over 50 years.


Cynthia Baldwin – former Penn State
 Vice President and General Counsel

Rather than deciding immediately, Dr. Spanier and the BOT hired a consulting firm to conduct a study to determine if an in-house counsel would better serve PSU.  Two weeks later, the firm came back and recommended that an in-house counsel would be a better alternative.  The decision was set.  PSU would get their own in-house counsel and replace McQuaide/Blasko.

At the time the decision was being debated, Cynthia Baldwin was attending the meetings as an emeritus trustee.  Shortly after the decision, Baldwin offered her name to be the in-house counsel.

Dr. Spanier believed that Baldwin would be a good fit for the job, considering that she was the President of the PSU BOT from 2004 to 2007 and was a former Justice on the Pennsylvania Supreme Court (appointed by Gov. Rendell).  

Baldwin's work history also included being the prosecuting attorney-in-charge in the OAG at the Bureau of Consumer Protection under LeRoy S. Zimmerman.  Zimmerman resigned from his chairman position at the Hershey Trust amid a scandal in which funds for the children were allegedly used to build a golf course.

Baldwin's hire was approved by the BOT and she began work as PSU General Counsel in February 2010.   The hiring announcement stated that Baldwin would serve in a transition role until a national search would be conducted to find a permanent in-house counsel.

Baldwin's Role As the General Counsel

The Freeh Report relied heavily on the statements and information from Cynthia Baldwin in several chapters of the report.  She was referenced at least 13 times in explaining the internal controls of the university.  Ironically, the PSU Office of General Counsel's (OGC)  policy AD49 reveals the counsel has no role in the oversight of policy or internal controls at the University.  The Freeh Report at 31 indicated a "Key Finding" that the University had no centralized office for oversight and compliance with laws and policies, but did not conclude that oversight and compliance should be the charge of the PSU OGC. It is notable that policy AD49 was revised substantially in July 2010, under Baldwin's watch.  Previous versions could not be obtained, however, the revised policy does state the the OGC handles all legal matters and subpoenas for the University.

Subpoeanas Not Served and/or Unanswered

According to Dr. Spanier, he never saw a single subpoena during his tenure as President of PSU.  In fact, Spanier stated that he believed he was voluntarily testifying before the grand jury.  Spanier also stated that he was surprised when Counselor Baldwin turned over a thumb drive containing all of his e-mail from 2004 to 2011 to the supervising judge. Spanier stated he relied heavily on Baldwin's advice and counsel throughout the investigation.

Grand Jury Subpoena 1179 was issued in Decenber 2010 and ordered PSU turn over all communications related to the Sandusky incidents on campus.  According to the Conspiracy of Nonsense grand jury presentment, the PSU IT staff were never provided with the subpoena nor told to seek any information pertaining to the subpoena.  If that is the case, how did Baldwin end up with a thumb drive full of e-mails?  Surely, she did not obtain them herself.

Governor Corbett implied the PSU could be charged with obstruction of justice for its failure to turn over the e-mails obtained by Inspector Clouseau's, er, Freeh's investigators.

Detectives and police investigators also testified that PSU was not quick to respond to the Subpoenas for the Office of Physical Plant Employees (Grand Jury Subpoeana 191 issued May 11, 2011) and the Athletic Department Football Support Staff (Grand Jury Subpoenas 183 and 185, May 10, 2011).

Baldwin's grand jury testimony in the November 2012 presentment states she dutifully presented all subpoenas to Spanier.  The presentment does not indicate that Spanier gave Baldwin any direction in handling the subpoenas and AD49 states the OGC "has the prerogative to send them to other parties after receipt."

The Question:  Was Baldwin Incompetent or Was She Purposely Undermining PSU Officials?

Informal polling of attorneys provided mixed reviews of Baldwin. One attorney called her "brilliant," while the majority were at the opposite end of the spectrum.

Were her actions in not answering or directing the subpoenas properly due to her incompetence or was she brought into PSU by the Business and Industry Trustees to obstruct the investigation and undermine PSU officials?  Baldwin's dual representation of PSU and of Tim Curley and Gary Schultz seem to be in favor of the latter.

It is clear from her background that Baldwin knows the inner workings of the BOT and that there may have been much more at stake in this scandal than the public knows.

Freeh's examination of the ties between PSU, the BOT, and The Second Mile was superficial at best.  And when asked at the press conference if the scandal involved any other PSU officials, Freeh answered, "No. Next question."

One has to wonder, what is lurking below the surface at Penn State that would make the President and the BOT agree with $60 million in fines and a massive hit to the school's reputation?

Again, we all are waiting for the answers.

Monday, January 14

Part IV: Second Mile Financials Don't Add Up: Who knew?

Prosecutor Joe McGettigan, in his opening statement at the Sandusky trial, said no one at the charity knew about Sandusky's abuse, but said "maybe" people at Penn State did.  Who were they?

By Ray Blehar

In the last installment of this series, we highlighted the escalating salaries of Dr. Jack Raykovitz and Katherine Genovese.  Their salaries began rising coincident with the first allegations of abuse against Jerry Sandusky and didn't stop rising until 2009.

Salaries don't tell the only story about who may have known about Sandusky.  Donations tell an equally interesting story.

Analyses of Second Mile donor lists from its annual reports from 2005 through 2010 revealed that a number of Penn State Board of Trustee members and/or their companies had strong financial ties to the organization. The chart below shows the donation history of current BOT members and/or their companies.  USSteel (Surma), Merck (Frazier), PNC Bank (Junker), Lloyd Huck, and Paul Silvis made considerable donations over the years to the Second Mile.  Surma was elected to the BOT in 2007 and Frazier in 2009.


Analysis

The red numbers indicate the years in which the news of the Sandusky scandal was shared among those with close ties to The Second Mile.  It is notable that there is a precipitious drop in the donations from USSteel, PNC Bank,  and Merck, but no such drop from Lloyd Huck or Paul Silvis.  Linda Strumpf made a considerable donation in 2010.  These donations provide insight into who may have known about the Sandusky investigation (Surma and Frazier) and who likely did not (Strumpf, Silvis,  and Huck).  

Was the drop in donations related to the investigation of Sandusky or could the drop have been related to Sandusky's 2009 retirement or to economic factors?

Sandusky's Retirement

Sandusky had told Raykovitz he was under investigation for child abuse and that he vowed to fight the charges.  In early 2009, he was indicated for child abuse and resigned from the charity.  The Second Mile Board decided to to keep silent about the abuse allegations, instead making an announcement that Sandusky had voluntarily retired.  Given that fact, Surma (USSteel) and Frazier (Merck) would not have gotten the news of the investigation through any official channel, since they were not Second Mile board members.

Economic Factors

The market crashed in late 2008, and many companies took large losses in the wake of the meltdown.  It appears that the drop in donations from USSteel could be tied to its financial performance.  The chart below shows a precipitous drop in stock price from 2008 to 2009 and it appears that John Surma is doing his level best to keep the company's stock prices low so that every American can be an owner of USSteel.  Share price closed today (1/14/13) at $24.38 -- down from about $200 per share in 2008.



Merck also had a significant drop in share price from 2008 to 2009, but nothing like that of USSteel.  Of course, Merck was not donating nearly as much as USSteel was to the Second Mile, contributing between $5000 and $10,000 per year in 2007 and 2008, before dropping the donation to between $1000 and $2000 in 2009.  In terms of percentage, however it is about an 80% drop.   Merck's stock closed at $43.34 today.

Other Than Money

PSU BOT member Ira Lubert donated $50,000 to The Second Mile back in 2002, but has not made a financial donation since, however, Lubert provided his Greenhills facility for Sandusky's camp in Reading until 2009.  Lubert also volunteered on the Board of Directors for the Southeast Region from at least 2005 to 2008  (we don't have the records from 2004).  There was no board of directors for the Southeast Region in 2003.  So is it just a coincidence that Lubert dropped off the Board and stopped letting TSM use his facilities in 2009?  Lubert was appointed to the BOT by the Governor in 2007, after serving previously from 1997 to 2000.  He was again reappointed in 2010 and his term is scheduled to end in 2013.

Freeh Investigation Does Not Reveal BOT's Relationships

Not so surprisingly, the $6.5 million dollar investigation ordered by the BOT didn't uncover any of this information.   Former FBI-Director, Louis Freeh's summation of PSU's relationship to The Second Mile consisted of two major themes:  the university's visible support of Second Mile and its provision of facilities gave Sandusky opportunities to bring young boys on campus; and, many Second Mile board members and program volunteers were alumni and students of Penn State.

At the Freeh Report Press Conference in July 2012, a suburban Philly alumna, Wendy Silverwood, asked Louis Freeh about what his "investigation" revealed about The Second Mile role in the scandal.

Freeh responded, "Well, I think you need to direct your question there.  We did as much as we could in that regard, relevant to our mandate.  Many of the people there would not speak to us. We didn't have access to their records.  We didn't have subpoena power as you know. But you raise a good question."

Clearly, Judge Freeh was dodging the question as all of his bureaucratic training prepared him to do.

As you have seen on this blog, there is plenty of information about The Second Mile in the public domain that raises serious questions.

When will we get answers?

NEXT:  Part V:  Financial Trends At Second Mile



Saturday, January 12

Duke, Penn State, and the Elephant in the Room

There are many parallels between the rushes to judgment in the Duke case and at Penn State.  The biggest difference between the two is the missing elephant at Duke.

by
Ray Blehar

Not too long ago someone posted Coach K's interview with CNN's Piers Morgan.  Coach K stated that the  PSU BOT should have handled things differently with regard to Paterno's dismissal -- and I think most people agree with that.  However, the most interesting part of the interview came at about the 1:00 minute mark when Piers asked:

"if such a situation had happened at Duke..."

Piers was talking about having a Sandusky like situation where someone is "innocent until proven guilty" and how the school should respond in such a situation.

I guess with the passage of time people forget.  Duke had a very similar rush to judgment with it's lacrosse team, who were immediately found guilty (by the media and the Duke administration) of raping a stripper.

The parallels in the case are quite striking.  Briefly:
-- an individual levied false charges at people at the university
-- a witness close to the individual did not corroborate the accuser's allegations
-- the accuser gave inconsistent accounts of the incident
-- the prosecutor pressed charges without possessing key evidence
-- the university and the media rushed to judgment and threw the accused under the bus immediately
-- evidence later came out that cleared the accused (most of us are waiting for the upcoming trials of Curley, Schultz, and Spanier to do just that).

Let's get to the specifics.

The Accusers

In the Duke case, the accuser, Crystal Mangum (a stripper), told police that members of the Duke lacrosse team raped her after her performance at one of the homes of the Duke players.   Mangum had been taken into custody by the police after an incident at a supermarket parking lot, where she refused to leave the car after an argument with the other stripper who worked the Duke party.

In the Penn State case, the accuser, Mike McQueary, told the police that he saw Sandusky doing something sexual with a young boy in the showers and that he had passed on the details to University officials.  The police were led to McQueary by an anonymous tip that he had told others about this incident in a chat room.

The Witness

In the Duke case, Mangum's co-worker, Kim Roberts, refuted Mangum's account of the rape. In her initial statement to police, Roberts said she was with Mangum the entire evening, except for five minutes.  Roberts was incredulous when she heard that Mangum had levied rape charges.

 In the Penn State case, Dr. Jonathon Dranov, refuted McQueary's account of him witnessing a sex act in the showers.  Dr. Dranov asked McQueary on three different occasions what he had seen and on none of those occasions did McQueary admit to seeing anything.  Dr. Dranov indicated the incident happened behind a wall and that McQueary saw an arm reach out and pull the child back behind the wall.

Inconsistencies

In the Duke case, Mangum initially told the police she was raped by twenty white players, but later reduced the number to three.  Mangum did not consistently choose the same three players when asked to identify them from photographs.  Also, she changed the time of the alleged rapes, first saying the occurred between  11:35 PM and midnight, which was refuted by phone records and photographs of her performing at the party.  Mangum reported several different accounts of the rape incident to the police, changing the details of how she was abused and who the attackers were.

In the Penn State case, McQueary initially told the police he looked into the showers twice.  After being hammered in the press for not stopping the alleged assault, he changed his stories to looking three times  and making sure the assault was stopped.  McQuery's testimony under cross examination at the preliminary perjury hearings in December 2011 was vague regarding what he told PSU officials (more on this in an upcoming blogpost). Finally, McQueary originally testified that the incident took place in 2002, but later the date was changed to 2001.

The Prosecutor Doesn't Have Evidence

In the Duke case, DA Mike Nifong, the prosecutor, ordered DNA testing of 46 of the 47 members of the Duke lacrosse team - excluding the one black player.  On April 10, 2006, the results came back showing that none  of the players' DNA was found on Mangum.  DA Nifong stated he had other evidence that would prove his case. On April 18, 2006, two players, Seligmann and Finnerty, were indicted on rape, kidnapping, and other charges.  On May 15, 2006, a third player, David Evans, was indicted for rape, kidnapping, and other charges.

In the Penn State case, then AG Tom Corbett initiated the investigation, but Linda Kelly had taken over by the time the investigation involved PSU.   John McQueary, Joe Paterno, Dr. Dranov, Tim Curley, and Gary Schultz were called as witnesses to verify McQueary's account. The anonymous tipster, nor anyone else who may have been in the chat with McQueary were not called as witnesses. Only one of the witnesses, Paterno, testified to an account that may have corroborated McQueary's allegations of a sexual assault.  Paterno later made a statement that he was not told of any of the specifics outlined in the grand jury testimony.  Despite the fact that the prosecution had no corroborating witness to the account McQueary told to Curley and Shultz, she charged both men with perjury and failure to report child abuse.  One year later, she levied perjury, failure to report, child endangerment, and criminal conspiracy against former PSU president, Graham Spanier.  She added the criminal conspiracy and child endangerment charges against Curley and Schultz.

The Rush To Judgment

In the Duke case, the University president, Richard Brodhead, made a decision to forfeit the next two lacrosse games, then eventually suspended the rest of the games that season.  He placed the players who had not yet graduated on suspension from the school.  The lacrosse coach, Mike Pressler, resigned over the scandal (later revealed he was forced).  The media framed the incident a privileged white athletes committing crimes against a black victim.  The public was outraged over the allegations and protested outside the players homes and at the courthouse. A candlelight vigil was held for the victim as part of a "Take Back the Night" march organized by students. DA Nifong used this characterization of the incident to his advantage, winning a close, racially polarized election.

In the Penn State case, the co-chair of the Penn State Board of Trustees, John Surma, made the decision to cancel Paterno's Tuesday morning press conference and fire President Graham Spanier and Joe Paterno.  AD Tim Curley was placed on adminstrative leave and Gary Schultz went back into retirement.  Paterno announced his intention to retire at year's end, but the BOT (led by Surma) terminated him shortly after he announced his retirement.  The media has framed the incident as top university officials and Paterno sacrificing children for the sake of the football program and the prestige of Penn State.  The public was outraged over the details (mostly false) contained in the grand jury presentment.  A candlelight vigil was held for the victims.  A fundraising effort to promote child abuse awareness was organized by students. Former AG Tom Corbett slow rolled the Sandusky investigation to not upset PSU supporters prior to the 2010 gubernatorial election and won the election by close to 10 points.

Evidence Reveals False Charges and Malicious Prosecution

In the Duke case, the DNA inconsistencies were announced in April 2006, yet Nifong pursued the case, essentially using Mangum's testimony as the evidence of rape and the other charges.  On December 22, 2006, Mangum admitted that she was not sure that she was raped.  Nifong dropped the rape charges, but continued to pursue the charges of kidnapping and other sex crimes.  On December 28, the North Carolina state bar filed ethics charges against Nifong for abuse of prosecutorial discretion by withholding the DNA evidence from the defense.  In January 2007, Nifong asked to be removed from the case and the case reassigned to the Attorney General, Roy Cooper.  In April 2007, Cooper proclaimed the Duke students innocent of all charges.

In the Penn State case, the inconsistencies in McQueary's story began almost immediately after the grand jury presentment was announced. On November 15, 2011, McQueary leaked an e-mail stating that he had broken up the incident and reported it to the police.  In December, McQueary testified that he had looked into the shower three times, not two as he previously testified and that he had slammed his locker to break up the activity.  In this original account of the incident, he looked twice, then immediately left the locker room. Under cross examination in December, McQueary stated he only told his father, Dranov, Paterno, Curley, and Schultz about the incident.  Apparently, Mike forgot about all those people he told in the chat room.  However, when asked who he told between observing the incident and reporting it to Curley and Schultz, he stated he could not remember if he told anyone else.  This begs the question, did McQueary tell other people who don't corroborate his story?   Perhaps, the AG knows the names of some of the "chatters," but has not revealed them.

The Elephant in the Room

What differentiates the Penn State case from the Duke case is the "elephant in the room."  In other words, an obvious truth that is being ignored.   That elephant is the role of The Second Mile Executive Director, Dr. Jack Raykovitz in not protecting the children of Second Mile from Jerry Sandusky

From the beginning, anyone who has followed this case knows the PSU AD Timothy Curley reported the Sandusky shower incident to Dr. Raykovitz, who was/is a mandated reporter under the law and should have immediately reported the incident to either CYS or DPW.   Raykovitz admitted discussing the incident with TSM board member, Bruce Heim, who considered it a non-incident.   As such, it was not shared with other TSM board members nor reported to authorities.

Inexplicably, AG Linda Kelly did not charge Raykovitz or Heim with failure to report or with child endangerment.  Also, in his opening statement at the Sandusky trial, prosecutor McGettigan stated that no one at Second Mile knew or had heard anything about Sandusky's abuse.

The Penn State BOT, who quickly threw its officials under the bus, made no mention that TSM should have reported it upon being informed by Curley.  The lawyers on the BOT could have easily justified that PSU officials complied with the law by reporting to TSM and defended the University.  Instead, they rolled over.

And the media has been stunningly silent on the matter, even though they often referred to TSM as a "victim farm" of Sandusky.

The Impending Investigation of the Sandusky Case

Recently elected AG Kathleen Kane stated the investigation of the Sandusky case would be among her top priorities once she takes office.  She will hire an assistant attorney general to lead the investigation and she vows to leave no stone unturned.  This will take time to get going, but we anxiously await that investigation.

However, I have a suggestion for Ms. Kane about what she should do immediately after being sworn in....

...charge Dr. Jack Raykovitz with failure to report child abuse and with endangering the welfare of children.

Wednesday, January 9

Media Malpractice in the Sandusky Scandal: Laziness or Collusion?

A local reporter got the facts wrong about the janitor's trial testimony.  Was he lazy or was he colluding with the OAG to perpetuate the false narrative about Penn State enabling Sandusky's crimes?

By Ray Blehar

While performing some research for my upcoming reports, I ran across a Centre Daily Times article by Mike Dawson that had some of the facts wrong about the trial testimony of Ronald Petrosky.

(I let Mr. Dawson know what I'd found-- I've yet to hear back from him)  Update:  Mr. Dawson contacted me and agreed that Petrosky could not have read what he said he did in the CDT.  Mr. Dawson also identified testimony problems of the police (Rossman) and of John McQueary.

Petrosky was the hearsay witness who testified about the 2000 shower incident where another janitor, James Calhoun, observed Sandusky performing oral sex on a young boy.

Conflicting Accounts

The key points of Petrosky's trial testimony were:
-- there was no curtain in the locker room ("There's no curtain in there.")
-- Calhoun (the eyewitness) was in the locker room for the duration of the incident
-- Petrosky entered the locker room after the incident and met Calhoun in the doorway
-- Petrosky called the police after reading the CDT's report "about the grad assistant"in March 2011

The CDT's Account said this:
-- the upper bodies of Sandusky and the child were blocked by a curtain
-- Calhoun came up to Petrosky to report the incident
-- Petrosky said he called authorities after seeing a story about Sandusky published in the CDT

Maybe Mike Dawson was confusing Petrosky's grand jury testimony with his trial testimony.  At the grand jury, Petrosky said he could only see legs because of an obstruction.  At trial, he said he could only see legs because he was looking down.  Thank goodness Mike didn't attempt to say where the crime occurred, because he may have again cited the grand jury version (Asst Coaches Locker Room) instead of the trial version (Staff Locker Room).

But everbody gets one  "mulligan" when they testify, right?

Just ask Tim Curley, Graham Spanier, and Gary Schultz.

Critical Facts Wrong

One would think that a reporter on top of his game - like Mr. Dawson - would have made a note to fact check Petrosky's statement about calling the police after reading "about the grad student" in the Centre Daily Times.  Petrosky's testimony follows:



A search of the CDT reveals that no articles concerning the grad assistant/McQueary appeared there until November 2011.  Petrosky testified he read about it in March 2011 -- before Sara Ganim broke the news of the Sandusky grand jury.   It would be reasonable to conclude that Petrosky "got it wrong" about how he found out about the incident. 

Wouldn't this enterprising reporter -- Mike Dawson -- want to know how Petrosky got this wrong?

(No, not when your job is to cover for the folks in Harrisburg and in Old Main)

So, how did he find out?  Enter, Anthony Sassano.

Agent Anthony Sassano

Agent Sassano stated that once the investigators found out about McQueary, they "brainstormed" about who else might know and came up with the idea to talk to the janitors.  The OAG subpoenaed (Grand Jury Subpoena 191) PSU for the lists of janitors names on May 11, 2011.  You can read Agent Sassano's trial testimony below and see that he "got it wrong" too -- the dates don't line up for him either.



Recap/Timeline

-- Sassano interviewed McQueary in November 2010.

-- Investigators obtained the 1998 police file in January 2011.

-- Petrosky talked to the police in March 2011 (after reading the CDT column).

-- Ganim broke the news on the grand jury on March 31, 2011.  The CDT linked to the PN story.

-- The list of Physical Plant Employees was subpoenaed in May 2011.

-- The story about McQueary appeared in the CDT on November 8, 2011.

Conclusion

There's a lot of mistakes in the testimony of Sassano and Petrosky.  Everything you've just read is on the public record.  Mike Dawson has access to this information just as much as anyone else does.  Is he too lazy to look it up?

One would think reporting suspected perjury by two more witnesses in the Sandusky case would be newsworthy.

It could mean a mistrial and Sandusky's release from jail -- and a firestorm the likes people haven't seen in a long time.  That storm would engulf the attorney general's office and turn this scandal upside down.

It's clear that the Centre Daily Times doesn't want to do anything to rock the boat and challenge the narratives emanating from Harrisburg and Old Main.

They too have decided "moving forward" (covering up) is more important than finding the truth.





Sunday, January 6

A Baker's Dozen

By SMSS FREEHdom Fighters

As we begin a new year, the FREEHdom Fighters thought it would be fun to present a bakery
box brimming with some of the most memorable quotes of 2012 surrounding the Sandusky
scandal.  

This “Bakers Dozen” of Ring Dings, Ho Hos, Devil Dogs, Twinkies, Moon Pies, Yodels and 
Krimpets are fun to look at and attractively wrapped, but in essence….stale, spongy, crème-
filled snacks with no substance or nutritional value. 




Pairs nicely with a glass of Kool-Aid.



NCAA President Mark Emmert

The NCAA issued "unprecedented sanctions" against Penn State in July 2012, slamming the way the school gave precedence to football success and lost focus on the first priority of any institution of higher learning: education.
"We want everyone to pay attention," NCAA President Mark Emmert said. "This is indeed a cautionary tale, that the athletic tail can't wag the academic dog."
However when  Mark Emmert was the Chancellor of Louisiana State University he certainly espoused a different philosophy of the importance of football when he fired football coach Gerry DiNardo in November 1999 ...

"The critical role of our football program is clear: it is of vital importance to the entire community: Our students, our fans and alumni worldwide and the state of Louisiana. Simply put, success in LSU football is essential for the success of Louisiana State University."
  
What is Emmert's true view of the first priority of institutions of higher learning?
 


Randy Feathers, Former Investigator for the PA AG
Until January 2011, only one state police trooper, his supervisor, plus an PA state attorney's agent working under Randy Feathers were assigned to the Jerry Sandusky case. In addition to supervising a unit out of Altoona, Randy Feathers also worked on the case himself.

“I was asked weekly if I had enough personnel,” Feathers said. “I never asked for help until 2011 when we had many more subpoenas and more evidence. Then I got eight more troopers and four more agents. If anyone wants to criticize, I’m the one to criticize because I made that decision weekly." 

“I didn’t want a whole lot of investigators on this case,” he continued. “You don’t want 20 different investigators going after a bunch of kids. You want to keep it as small as possible.”


However, psychologist Mike Gillum, who counseled Aaron Fisher (Victim 1), immediately after he and his mother walked through the door of Clinton County's Children and Youth Services office in November 2009, provides a much different account than Feathers'.
Gillum co-authored a book, "Silent No More: Victim 1's Fight for Justice Against Jerry Sandusky," with Aaron Fisher (Victim 1) and his mother, Dawn Daniels. In it Gillum gives a detailed chronology of what went on behind the scenes. Gillum states that he became frustrated as the investigation slowed and prosecutors told him many times that an arrest was imminent. He also blamed Governor Tom Corbett for delaying the investigation when he was the attorney general and at the same time running for governor.

Randy Feathers is still employed by Tom Corbett. Corbett named Feathers to the Board of Probation and Parole in September, 2012. 
  
Why didn’t you ask for more help Randy?
 
 
Frank Noonan - former head of AG criminal
 investigations and current Commissioner
 of the Pennsylvania State Police
Following his retirement from the FBI in 1998, Frank Noonan was appointed Northeast Regional Director for the Attorney General’s Bureau of Narcotics investigation. After 11 years as Regional Director, Noonan was promoted to Chief of Criminal investigation for the PA Office of the Attorney General in July 2009 under Tom Corbett’s watch.  After Tom Corbett became governor, Frank Noonan was nominated on January 18, 2011, to be Commissioner of Pennsylvania State Police (PSP) and was confirmed by the State Senate on April 12, 2011.
 
Paterno may have fulfilled his legal requirement to report suspected abuse by former assistant football coach Jerry Sandusky, state police Commissioner Frank Noonan said, "but somebody has to question about what I would consider the moral requirements for a human being that knows of sexual things that are taking place with a child." Noonan added: "I think you have the moral responsibility, anyone. Not whether you're a football coach or a university president or the guy sweeping the building. I think you have a moral responsibility to call us."

However, in December 2012 the Associated Press released a story titled, Pa. troopers’ Asian sex Trips surface in lawsuit.

Records in a case pending in federal court in Pennsylvania say the three PA state police lieutenants, Martin Kruse and Lawver, all admitted that they hired prostitutes in Thailand and Vietnam on trips between 2002 and 2008, according to a February 2009 general investigative report filed with the state police's Bureau of Integrity and Professional Standards.

Child prostitution is a particular problem in Thailand and some other Asian countries.  State police leadership and internal affairs assigned to investigate the sex trips questioned the ages of the prostitutes repeatedly. The three state policemen have insisted that none was underage, records show.

"There was no indication, wherever they went, that there was [sic] any children involved, which is what our concern was".

"The age of the prostitutes they were with was not a concern to Lt. Martin (because according to him, they all looked old enough)."

Internal PA state police records examined by the Associated Press shows the three supervisors evaded significant punishment. Additionally, the U.S. attorney's office in Harrisburg said a federal investigation regarding the Asian sex tourism trips was closed without charges being filed, and prosecutors declined further comment.

Why aren’t your colleagues held to the same “moral standards” Frank? 

 


Tom Corbett, Governor of PA and former 
PA State Attorney General
 
In May of 2010, while running for Governor, State Attorney General Tom Corbett subpoenaed Twitter to appear as a Grand Jury witness to “testify and give evidence regarding alleged violations of the laws of Pennsylvania”.


The subpoena ordered Twitter to provide “any and all subscriber information” of the person(s) behind two accounts – @bfbarbie and @CasaBlancaPA – which at the time of the subpoena had  only 68 and 123 followers, respectively— and had been criticizing Corbett in 140 characters or less on the popular social media site.



It’s interesting that Governor Corbett was so quick to issue the subpoenas of critics’ Twitter accounts but the Second Mile didn’t receive subpoenas until January 2011 in the Jerry Sandusky case which the PA AG’s office opened in early 2009. Sandusky’s home wasn’t searched until the summer of 2011 and a second subpoena for The Second Mile financial records wasn’t delivered until after Sandusky was charged November 4, 201l. PA Senate Democratic Leader Jay Costa of Allegheny County said, in hindsight, the matter could have been handled differently.


Tom, why did you subpoena Social Media and not a Social Menace?

 


Rodney Erickson – Penn State University President
Rodney Erickson told "Outside the Lines" on July 25, 2012 that if Penn State had not accepted the package of NCAA sanctions announced on July 23, the Nittany Lions faced a historic death penalty of four years.

However, in an interview with Adam Rittenburg of ESPN the same week, Ed Ray, Oregon State president chair the NCAA's executive committee which sanctioned Penn State and represented the presidents and chancellors at the NCAA news conference, categorically denied that the suspension of play was threatened if Penn State did not agree to the consent decree.

When questioned during an open Q&A during the September Board of Trustees meeting, Erickson stood steadfastly behind the account he offered trustees in an August 12, 2012 teleconference, in which he said he was told that an overwhelming majority of NCAA officials "wanted blood" and the consent decree was "a take-it-or-leave-it proposition."
"Those are the facts ... I still believe that was the best course of action given what we were faced with," Erickson said. "It's a decision that no university president should ever have to make." 

Rodney, will we ever learn the truth?

 

11.9.11 Penn State Board of Trustees


In the November 9, 2011 press conference where John Surma announced that … “Joseph Paterno is no longer the football coach -- Effective immediately.”  During the Q&A portion of the presser, Surma was asked  by a reporter,  “Sir, what was the driving reason of removing coach Paterno? “ he answered, “In consideration of all the facts and the difficulties that we are encountering during this time, it was the trustees' view that it was in the best interest, long-term interests of our university to make that change.”

Later we find out that Joe was slipped a note by Fran Ganter which had John Surma's name and cellphone number scribbled on it. Paterno called Surma from his kitchen phone where Surma informed him that the board of trustees had "terminated" him as head coach, "effective immediately."  He hung up the phone and broke the news to his wife of 49 years, Sue.

A moment later a second call was made to Surma where Sue Paterno said, "After 61 years, he deserved better." Then she hung up.

In January 2012 the Penn State trustees, in an attempt to change the public’s perception of how they handled the firing of Joe Paterno, spoke to the New York Times resulting in an article titled, Penn State’s Trustee Recount Painful Decision to Fire Paterno . In it they outline their rationale for firing Joe Paterno: “The trustees also laid out what they said were three key reasons for firing Paterno: his failure to do more when told about the suspected sexual assault in 2002; what they regarded as his questioning of the board’s authority in the days after Sandusky’s arrest; and what they determined to be his inability to effectively continue coaching in the face of continuing questions surrounding the program.”

However, the Penn State community was persistent and not ready to “Move on”. They continued to raise questions as to why Joe Paterno was fired. Therefore, on March 12, 2012 the Penn State Board of Trustees board felt obligated to issue another statement to “state clearly” the reasons for his dismissal: a “failure of leadership" for his actions following a reported sex assault involving former assistant Jerry Sandusky. The board found that while Paterno fulfilled a legal obligation to tell his superiors that an employee claimed Sandusky abused a young boy in a shower, it said Paterno should have done more. "We determined that his decision to do his minimum legal duty and not to do more to follow up constituted a failure of leadership by Coach Paterno," the trustees wrote. 
Letter firing Joe Paterno from Cynthia Baldwin 
Penn State Vice President and General Counsel

 
However, the Board of Trustees neglects to mention that they had a second chance to speak to Joe on that fateful night when Sue Paterno called them back. Additionally, none of those plans was mentioned in the certified letter written by Penn State general counsel, Cynthia Baldwin and sent to Paterno one week after he was fired. It begins, "Pursuant to your termination … we are asking you to make the following arrangements.”



By April 4, 2012 Don Van Natta Jr. writes, “Joe Paterno was not fired. That’s what the board of trustees now says. He was simply relieved of his coaching duties but was allowed to continue on as an emeritus professor and would be paid his full salary under his contract, the trustee said in the weeks and months since then.  In a statement released on March 12, the trustees said that if Paterno had not hung up the phone so quickly, Surma had intended to tell him that the board was sorry for firing him by phone and that it was the board’s intention to fulfill his employment contract. They also said that it was always their intention to name Paterno “head coach emeritus,” a title that bestows honor and privileges.”

11.9.11 Penn State Board of Trustees, was Joe fired or not? 

 


Mark Schwarz – ESPN Reporter
In 2003, Mark Schwartz and his producer, Arty Berko interviewed repeatedly Bobby Davis, the former Syracuse ball boy after Davis had contacted ESPN's Outside the Lines with information alleging that longtime Syracuse associate head basketball coach Bernie Fine had molested him as a child. At Davis’ request in 2003, Schwarz and Berko also interviewed Davis’ step-brother, Mike Lang. According to Schwarz, Lang told the ESPN reporters that "Bernie grabbed my leg a few times but he didn't really do too much to me and I don't have anything to say to you." 
 
The network ultimately opted not to run the story because, according to ESPN officials, there were no other victims who would talk, and no independent evidence to corroborate Bobby Davis’ story.

However, as the Jerry Sandusky scandal unfolded and was so eerily similar to what Bernie Fine did to Davis, Davis texted his stepbrother, Mike Lang that he could not deal with it. Lang felt obligated to help his brother and called Mark Schwarz.

As irony would have it, the call to Schartz came in on November 11, 2011 just as he was about to leave the ESPN satellite truck to attend the candlelight vigil and moment of silence held in support of the alleged victims that evening on the Penn State campus. After reporting from the vigil, Schwarz called Lang back. The two men spoke for some time and Schwarz recalls Lang as "frantic, tearful and emotional."

ESPN aired its first story breaking the Bernie Fine scandal on Nov. 17 in which Davis, now 39, and Lang, now 45, accused Fine of molesting them, starting in the late 1970s and continuing into the 1990s. Ten days later, the network ran a second story with an audio tape, that ESPN had in its possession since 2003, which recorded a 2002 phone call that Davis recorded with Fine's wife, Laurie. ESPN stated that it added the audiotape after it hired a voice recognition expert to confirm that it was Laurie Fine’s voice on the tape.

Many have questioned why ESPN did not share the tape with police or administrators at Syracuse, even if the network believed the unauthenticated tape created a journalistic obstacle to airing the story.  In an interview with Anderson Cooper, Schwarz said that "journalists are not necessarily required or expected to hand over evidence that they did not obtain or create themselves to the police."


The Huffington Post reported, Bob Rucker, interim director of San Jose State University's department of journalism and mass communications, had this to say about the responsibilities of a journalist in such a situation when he was interviewed by FOX Sports.

"Since we are covered by the First Amendment, we don't have to turn over anything," Rucker told FOX. "Still, it's not always that obvious, especially when it comes to protecting the interests of children. I know I'd be hard-pressed not to go to my bosses and tell them I need to talk to the police."

Why did you hold on to the “Bernie Fine” tape so long Mark?

 


Kenneth Frazier - Penn State Trustee 
Elected by Business and Industry
Ken Frazier, Penn State alum, Harvard-trained lawyer and current chairman and CEO of the Merck pharmaceutical company, also headed the Board of Trustees “full and complete” investigation into the Sandusky matter.  In late November 2011, Frazier, announced that it had hired Freeh to look specifically at how the culture, policies, and practices of the university and its administration could have allowed the alleged sexual abuse to happen on campus and go unreported for so long. It will also seek to make recommendations to the board as to how to prevent similar events from ever occurring again, Frazier said. "No one is above scrutiny," Frazier said.

Frazier is a man with a track record of protecting powerful institutions from the consequences of their inaction and is best known for his phenomenal success in defending a sordid chapter in Merck’s recent past—its years-long silence about the safety problems of the popular painkiller Vioxx proving that he is skilled at preparing a no-hold barred defense that minimizes liabilities to potential plaintiffs. Not only did his hard-nosed tactics pay off for Merck in 2007 but they paid off personally for Frazier who became chairman and CEO of Merck in 2011. 


This is the same man who had this to say about Joe Paterno four days before Paterno died on January 22, 2012, “To me, it wasn’t about guilt or innocence in a legal sense,” Frazier said of Paterno’s decision not to go to police. “It was about these norms of society that I’m talking about: that every adult has a responsibility for every other child in our community. And that we have a responsibility not to do the minimum, the legal requirement. We have a responsibility for ensuring that we can take every effort that’s within our power not only to prevent further harm to that child, but to every other child.” 
 

Mr. Frazier, how do you reconcile that statement with your actions in defending the Vioxx suit at Merck?



However, once the Freeh report was released and implicated Pennsylvania State University's board of trustees alongside its top school officials, Frazier had this to say, "We failed to ask the right questions, the tough questions, or to take definitive action, Put simply, we did not force the issue."

So “in hindsight”, Ken, you wish you” had done more”?

When pressed about why the Board of Trustees did not force the issue with Dr. Graham Spanier, Penn State University President at the time, Frazier had this to say, “We were also being told there were restrictions based on grand-jury secrecy about what could be said at a particular point in time," he said

So how does the same legal-eagle, who defended Merck so successfully against the Vioxx class-action lawsuit, not know enough to push the issue of grand jury secrecy?


Will the real Kenneth Frazier please stand up?

 

Mark Dambly – Penn State Trustee


Critics of the Board of Trustees handling of the Freeh report have said that Penn State has “accepted” the findings, but Mark Dambly said that wasn’t the case.

The board said in a statement after the findings were released July 12 that it accepted full responsibility for the failures which occurred.


"There have been lots of suggestions that we accepted all 267 pages (of the report). That's not accurate at all," Dambly said. "We did not take any action on the Freeh report. It's open to anybody's interpretation."

Freeh challenged the trustees to look at the culture of the university. But, Dambly said, "We don't suggest that the entire culture of the university is flawed. None of us have ever said that. Unfortunately, it's been construed that way." 

 

What ARE you trying to say, Mark?

 


Carl Shaffer – Penn State Trustee
 elected by Agriculture Societies
In late July 2012, following the release Freeh report, PA auditor general, Jack Wagner sent a letter to the PA State Legislature that his office is working on a comprehensive report on Penn State, which was separate from the university-sanctioned Freeh report, outlining preliminary recommendations that Wagner said were necessary to improve the university's governance in the wake of the Jerry Sandusky child sex abuse scandal. 

As auditor general, Wagner is the state’s top government watchdog and has responsibility for ensuring all state money is spent legally. Because Penn State is a state-financed university, any change would have to be made by the General Assembly. After the Wagner letter was received by the State legislature, PA State Representative Scott Conklin introduced legislation based on Auditor General's recommendations to alter the structure and governance of the Penn State Board of Trustees. 

Wagner’s final report was released on November 14, 2012. Some of the main highlights from the report included: removing the university president from the board of trustees; removing the governor as a voting member of the board; reducing the board’s size to improve transparency and accountability; and preventing trustees from becoming high-ranking university employees, such as when the trustees made fellow trustee David Joyner the interim athletic director in November 2011.

It didn’t take long to get a reaction on the proposed reforms from current Penn State trustee, Carl Shaffer. “This is our university — this university is unique in a lot of ways from other universities,” said Shaffer during a committee meeting Thursday on governance issues. “I think it’s up to this board to decide how we’re going to take this university forward.”

You’re kidding Carl, aren’t you?

 


Karen Peetz – Chairman of the
Penn State Board of Trustees

Karen Peetz was elected to the Penn State Board of Trustees in 2010 and was elected Chairman of the Board in 2012. In December 2012, she was named President of Bank of New York Mellon. Prior to this appointment she was a Vice Chairman, with responsibility for the Financial Markets & Treasury Services (FMTS) group within BNY Mellon, which is the corporate brand of The Bank of New York Mellon Corporation. The businesses that make up the FMTS group – treasury services, corporate trust, depositary receipts, clearing services (Pershing), broker-dealer clearing, collateral management and alternative investment services – represent more than 40 percent of the company’s revenue. Each of these businesses commands a leading global market position and ranks among the company’s most visible and best-performing franchises. Karen is a member of BNY Mellon’s Executive Committee, the organization’s most senior management body, which oversees the firm’s day-to-day operations.

As Chairman of the Penn State Board of Trustees, Peetz was more than willing to comment on the Freeh report after it was released in July, 2012 when she spoke to Jeff Brady of NPR News. Brady asked Peetz if the report would change how the university honors Paterno. Peetz’s response, “I think our reaction is that the clarity that's come out of the report would show that 61 years of excellent service that Joe gave to the university is now marred. And we have to step back and say, what does that mean?”

In November 2012,   a BNY Mellon subsidiary, Ivy Asset Management, agreed to a $210 million settlement for advising clients to invest with Bernard L. Madoff, whose multibillion-dollar fraud landed him in federal prison, New York’s attorney general, Eric T. Schneiderman. “Ivy Asset Management violated its fundamental responsibility as an investment adviser by putting its own pecuniary interests ahead of the interests of its clients,” Mr. Schneiderman said. “Ivy deliberately concealed negative facts it uncovered in its due diligence of Madoff in order to keep earning millions of dollars in fees. As a result, its clients suffered massive and avoidable losses.”


BNY Mellon did not immediately reply to requests for comment.

Why No Comment, BYN Mellon President Peetz?

 


Cynthia Baldwin – former Penn State
 Vice President and General Counsel



Cynthia Baldwin, a former Pennsylvania state Supreme Court justice and past chair of the Penn State Board of Trustees, served as Penn State University's general counsel during the grand jury investigation of Jerry Sandusky before she stepped down in January 2012. Baldwin was repeatedly cited in the Freeh report for possible missteps in her handling of the matter.
"Baldwin told the Special Investigative Counsel that she went to the grand jury appearances as the attorney for Penn State, and that she told both Curley and Schultz that she represented the university and that they could hire their own counsel if they wished."
However, according to the transcript from the grand jury, both men said they believed Ms. Baldwin was representing them.

"You have counsel with you?" the prosecutor asked Mr. Curley.
"Yes, I do," he answered.
"Would you introduce her, please?" the prosecutor continued.
"My counsel is Cynthia Baldwin."

Mr. Schultz said the same when he was questioned.
"You are accompanied today by counsel, Cynthia Baldwin, is that correct?" the prosecutor asked.
"That is correct," Mr. Schultz answered.

Since Penn State was not a party to the criminal investigation, legal experts question Ms. Baldwin's presence in the grand jury room.  If she was a representative of the university, she had no business at the grand jury.

"The most significant matter in terms of ethics is what happened in the grand jury room," Mr. Ledewitz said. "The first thing you learn in legal ethics is to know who the client is."

Even though Baldwin has insisted that she was not representing Spanier, Curley and Shultz, when they testified before a grand jury investigating Sandusky's crimes, prosecutors now say the record shows she was.

Cynthia, who were you representing and where were your legal ethics?